Rainwater Collection Barrels vs Diverter Systems
Rain barrel vs downspout diverter kit: closed 50-gallon barrels vs diverter systems that turn any container into a rain barrel with overflow control.
RTS Home Accents 50-Gallon Rain Water Collection Barrel with Brass Spigot, Oak Color
RTS Home Accents
WADEO Rainwater Collection System, Downspout Diverter Fits for 2"x 3" or 3"x 4" Residential Downspouts, Rain Barrel Diverter Kit with Adjustable Valve and Filter, 5FT Hose, Black
WADEO
Catching rainwater off your roof is smart, but there are two different ways to do it — and people confuse them constantly. A rain barrel is a sealed, purpose-built container you place under a downspout. A diverter kit is a fitting that taps into the downspout and routes water into whatever container you already have. The right choice depends on whether you want a turnkey barrel or the flexibility to use your own storage.
The Core Difference
A rain barrel is a self-contained, closed 50-gallon tank with a spigot and a sealed lid. It’s ready to use the day it arrives, keeps mosquitoes and sunlight out, and needs nothing but a downspout positioned over it. Its limit is fixed capacity and overflow management in a heavy storm.
A diverter kit mounts onto your existing downspout and diverts a portion of the flow through a hose into a container of your choosing — a barrel, a stock tank, or any food-safe vessel. It includes a filter to keep debris out and a valve to shut off or regulate flow, and it routes excess water back down the spout so nothing floods your foundation.
| What you get | Barrel: a closed 50-gallon tank · Diverter: a downspout fitting + hose + filter |
| Storage | Barrel: fixed 50-gallon capacity · Diverter: works with any container |
| Overflow | Barrel: needs its own overflow plan · Diverter: auto-routes excess down the spout |
| Setup | Barrel: place and connect · Diverter: cut into downspout and assemble |
| Mosquito / algae | Barrel: sealed lid blocks both · Diverter: depends on your container's lid |
If You Want Turnkey and Sealed, Buy a Barrel
A closed 50-gallon barrel is the simplest path to collecting rainwater: it’s sealed against mosquitoes and sunlight (the two things that turn stored water foul), it has a brass spigot for a hose, and it’s ready the day it arrives. The trade-off is that 50 gallons fills fast in a real storm, so you need a clear overflow path — or a second barrel.
RTS Home Accents 50-Gallon Rain Water Collection Barrel with Brass Spigot, Oak Color
RTS Home Accents
Embrace nature's solution to our emerging water shortage-collect rainwater. When drought sets in and rain is short, rain barrels can provide that precious water you need for your l…
- 50-Gallon Capacity: Provides ample storage for harvested rainwater, ideal for watering gardens, lawns, and plants.
- Durable Construction: Rain Barrel is made from UV-resistant polyethylene to withstand outdoor elements and ensure long-l…
- Overflow Valve: Built-in overflow valve for managing excess water and the option to connect multiple barrels for increas…
- Sleek, Textured Design: Blends seamlessly with outdoor décor for an attractive and functional addition to your yard. Fla…
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
If You Want Flexibility or Already Have a Container, Buy a Diverter
A diverter kit is the better route when you want to use a larger or cheaper container, or when you don’t want to cut and reposition the downspout more than once. The built-in filter keeps leaves and grit out of your stored water, and the valve automatically routes overflow back down the spout — solving the foundation-flooding problem that plagues basic barrel setups.
WADEO Rainwater Collection System, Downspout Diverter Fits for 2"x 3" or 3"x 4" Residential Downspouts, Rain Barrel Diverter Kit with Adjustable Valve and Filter, 5FT Hose, Black
WADEO
- 【Designed to Keep Debris Out and Water Flowing】Our rainwater harvesting system features a built-in filter that traps lea…
- 【Compatibility】Perfectly fits standard 2×3-inch or 3×4-inch residential downspouts. Please install the rain barrel diver…
- 【Flexible Water Collection】Easily adjust the water flow to control rainwater intake or shut it off completely when the b…
- 【Premium PP Material】Made of high-grade PP material that is more durable than standard PVC. UV-resistant, corrosion-resi…
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
The Verdict
Buy a sealed rain barrel if you want the simplest, most set-and-forget option and 50 gallons is enough. Buy a diverter kit if you already have a suitable container, want more capacity, or want automatic overflow management built in. The two aren’t rivals so much as different starting points — and a barrel plus a proper diverter is the setup that actually survives a heavy downpour without flooding your foundation.
Frequently Asked Questions
How fast does a 50-gallon rain barrel fill? Faster than most people expect — in a heavy storm, a typical roof section can fill a 50-gallon barrel in under 15 minutes. That’s why overflow management matters more than capacity for a basic barrel setup.
Can I connect two rain barrels together? Yes — most barrels have a linking port or you can run a hose between spigots. A second barrel doubles capacity, but you still need a clear overflow path for when both fill during a downpour.
Do I need to winterize a rain barrel? In freezing climates, yes — drain it and store it or leave the spigot open before the first hard freeze, because expanding ice can crack the plastic. A diverter has the same risk if water sits in the line.
How do I keep mosquitoes out of a diverter-fed container? The container’s lid does that job — a sealed lid blocks both mosquitoes and sunlight (which feeds algae). A diverter with a built-in filter keeps debris out of the water, but it doesn’t seal your container; that’s on your choice of barrel or tank.
